Trump admin asks Supreme Court to revive third-country deportation rule

Trump Administration Urges Supreme Court to Reinstate Third-Country Deportations Without Hearings

The Trump administration filed an emergency request with the Supreme Court on Thursday, asking the justices to revive its controversial policy of deporting certain migrants to countries other than their nations of origin. The practice, often referred to as “third-country removal,” was struck down by a lower court on the grounds that it violates the due process rights of deportees. The Justice Department’s emergency appeal marks the latest legal battle in a case that has repeatedly tested the boundaries of executive power over immigration enforcement.

At the center of the dispute is a February 2026 order from a federal judge in Boston, which was largely upheld by an appellate court last week. That order requires federal immigration officials to give deportees more due process before removing them to a so-called “third country” — a nation where the individual has no citizenship, residence, or apparent ties. Specifically, the courts have said that migrants must receive notice and be given a meaningful opportunity to challenge their deportation before the government can send them to such a country.

The policy in question has allowed the Department of Homeland Security to send detained migrants to third nations without first providing them with notice or a chance to contest the removal, as long as the receiving country has made blanket assurances that it will not persecute or torture the deportees. Administration lawyers argue that these diplomatic assurances are sufficient to protect migrants from harm and that requiring additional process would cripple an important tool in the government’s broader immigration enforcement strategy.

According to Justice Department lawyers, the practical consequences of the lower court rulings were immediate and significant. DHS was forced to cancel a flight that had been scheduled to carry roughly 70 would-be deportees to three different third countries. Some of those individuals, the lawyers noted, had criminal records. The cancellation came as a direct result of the adverse decisions issued by judges in Boston, who have emerged as key judicial roadblocks to the administration’s immigration agenda.

In the emergency appeal, Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued that the third-country removal policy has already enabled the Trump administration to remove “thousands” of individuals in recent months. He further estimated that “thousands more” are eligible to be deported to third countries under the policy. Sauer characterized these individuals as including “some of the worst of the worst criminal aliens — whose home countries refuse to take them back.”

Sauer also emphasized that the policy has been in effect for 15 months, largely because of earlier court orders that allowed it to proceed while litigation continued. He warned that the latest judicial intervention would once again obstruct DHS from efficiently removing aliens from the United States. But the Solicitor General went further, arguing that the lower court’s decision “undermines our standing abroad.”

“Finding third countries willing and able to accept aliens is a delicate diplomatic endeavor,” Sauer wrote in the emergency application. “By interjecting itself in that process, and potentially disrupting those carefully negotiated arrangements, the lower courts’ actions ‘will cause significant and irreparable harm to U.S. foreign policy.'”

The emergency appeal was assigned to Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, who handles emergency requests arising from Massachusetts and other states in the geographic region. Jackson gave lawyers representing the immigrants challenging the policy until Monday afternoon to file a response. Sauer asked Jackson to provide the administration with temporary relief while the full Supreme Court considers whether to take up the matter.

This case is part of the Trump administration’s far-reaching crackdown on illegal immigration, which has included a wide range of enforcement measures and diplomatic initiatives. As part of that effort, the administration has brokered agreements with dozens of countries around the world, particularly in Africa and Latin America, that have agreed to accept deportees from the United States who are not their own citizens. The arrangement allows the U.S. to remove individuals who cannot be sent back to their home countries, either because those countries refuse to take them or because the migrants have legal protections preventing removal to their homelands.

The choice of destination countries has drawn scrutiny from human rights advocates and immigrant rights groups. Some of the African nations that have agreed to participate in the third-country deportation program are plagued by repressive governments, armed conflict, human rights abuses, and widespread poverty. Among the countries named in the original reporting are Equatorial Guinea, the Central African Republic, and South Sudan. Critics have questioned whether such nations can genuinely provide safety to deportees who have no prior connection to them and may not speak the local language or have any support network there.

The administration, however, has moved forward with the program, and the profile of deportees sent to these countries has varied widely. Some countries, such as Eswatini and South Sudan, have received deportees from the Trump administration who have violent and serious criminal histories. Those individuals, according to officials, are precisely the kind of dangerous aliens the policy is designed to remove from American communities. Other nations, however, have accepted people with no known criminal record beyond immigration violations in the United States.

Liberia is one such country. In a recent report, CBS News interviewed men and women from Brazil, Colombia, Guatemala, Honduras, and Venezuela who were deported to the West African country last month. The deportees described feeling stateless and disoriented after being sent to a country they had never visited and with which they had no cultural, familial, or linguistic ties. All of them said they were deported to West Africa without being notified in advance and without being given any opportunity to challenge the deportation. Their accounts illustrate the human cost of the policy and the due process concerns that have animated the legal challenges against it.

Immigration officials have mainly targeted two categories of individuals in their third-country deportation campaign. The first includes immigrants who have won limited legal protections in U.S. immigration courts that bar ICE from deporting them to their homelands. For these individuals, deportation to their country of origin might put them at risk of persecution, torture, or other harm. The second category includes detainees whose home countries limit or reject U.S. deportations altogether, leaving the government with no easy way to remove them.

The administration’s legal fight over third-country removals has already reached the Supreme Court once before, though at an earlier stage in the proceedings. In a divided decision last year, the high court allowed the Trump administration to resume deportations to third countries while the legal challenges continued. At that time, the Supreme Court lifted an order from the federal judge in Boston that had prevented the administration from removing immigrants without first giving them the chance to raise fears of torture or persecution. That earlier ruling was seen as a significant victory for the administration, allowing the policy to move forward despite ongoing litigation.

Now, with the lower courts once again imposing new procedural requirements, the administration is asking the Supreme Court to step in once more. The outcome of this emergency appeal could have major implications for the future of third-country deportations and for the broader scope of executive authority over immigration removals.

Supporters of the policy argue that it is a necessary and effective tool for dealing with a broken immigration system, particularly when home countries refuse to cooperate with U.S. deportation efforts. They contend that requiring additional process for every deportee would bog down the system and allow dangerous individuals to remain in the country longer. They also point to the diplomatic assurances obtained from receiving countries as sufficient safeguards against mistreatment.

Opponents, by contrast, argue that sending people to countries where they have no ties and where they may face unknown dangers is not only cruel but unconstitutional. They insist that the government must provide notice and a hearing before removing anyone to a third country, especially when the individual may have legitimate fears of persecution or torture. The fact that some deportees have been sent to nations with poor human rights records only heightens those concerns.

As the Monday deadline approaches, all eyes will be on the Supreme Court. The justices will have to weigh the administration’s asserted national security and foreign policy interests against the constitutional rights of the migrants affected. Whatever the Court decides, the case is likely to remain a flashpoint in the ongoing national debate over immigration enforcement, due process, and the limits of presidential power.

Share This Article
mediawatchbot
11 Min Read