Shane Gillis Breaks Silence on Controversial SNL Monologue: ‘They Don’t Approve It’
Shane Gillis is speaking out after his October appearance on Saturday Night Live sparked intense backlash. The 38-year-old comedian, who returned to the long-running NBC sketch show as a host years after being fired from the cast, addressed the controversy during a Friday, November 13 episode of The Joe Rogan Experience podcast. During that conversation, Gillis revealed that SNL personnel did not pre-approve the monologue that landed him in hot water.
“Not to defend SNL — they don’t approve it,” Gillis said, according to the episode. “I mean, they could shut it down.” He went on to recall what he told show staff before taking the live stage. “I’m giving you a solid C minus of a monologue, but I promise there’s no controversy,” he said.
That prediction did not hold. During the October 10 show, Gillis delivered a monologue that immediately drew criticism for comments about women’s workout clothing. The comedian, known for his blunt, often provocative stand-up style, joked that he had been away from the gym for so long that he was shocked by what women now wear while exercising.
“I haven’t been to the gym in so long, I didn’t know women just dress like whores now? Look, I’m sorry, there’s no other way to describe [it],” Gillis said at the time. He went on to describe the bright, tight shorts he claimed to have seen, delivering a crude and detailed description of how the fabric clings to the body. “And don’t look! You’re not allowed to look,” he added.
The remarks ignited immediate and widespread condemnation online. Many social media users criticized Gillis for shaming women and for using language that they argued perpetuated harmful attitudes toward women. The backlash was amplified by the fact that it came while many people were already engaged in conversations about sexual violence, including the Jane Doe Cornell gang rape allegations. In that climate, several Hollywood figures felt compelled to respond publicly.
One of the most prominent voices was Schitt’s Creek star Dan Levy, who shared a video on Instagram on October 11. Levy did not hold back. “Women wearing short shorts to the gym does not make them whores,” he said. “It makes the men calling them whores misogynists. There’s a difference there.” Levy went on to note that he had seen far more male skin at the gym than female bodies being flaunted. “I’ve seen more men’s nipples at the gym than I’ve ever seen women showing their bodies off,” he said.
Levy also expressed disbelief that such a moment could air on live national television. “But I’m speechless that something like that can exist on live national television,” he continued. “And to be perfectly honest, more men need to be standing up in opposition to it because it’s complacency that has created the environment [in] which women are sexually assaulted, and it’s a conversation as opposed to a crime.” He argued that the issue was not solely a women’s issue but a societal one. “This is not a women’s issue. This is an everybody issue, because the more that men objectify women in the media, the more that other men see them as objects and treat them as objects. They are not objects. They are superior human beings to men, OK? And I’m sorry if this gets me in trouble with the internet, but f***.”
Levy’s video was widely shared, and his comments became a focal point in the larger debate about the monologue. But not everyone agreed with the criticism. Gillis also found defenders from within the comedy world, including former SNL cast member Dana Carvey, comedian David Spade, and British comic Jimmy Carr. Carvey, 71, and Spade, 62, discussed the situation on their podcast in October. Carvey said he did not understand why the joke had caused so much outrage. He framed it as a classic stand-up bit rather than a literal statement about women. “I just didn’t understand the kerfuffle only because, to me, I just saw it as what we call it — I’ll just say it — a joke,” Carvey said. “Like, when you say jokes, you’re not literally saying women are whores. You are literally joking. Isn’t that kind of the idea? No? Did I just get canceled?” Spade and Carr were among several comedians who expressed sympathy for Gillis and concern about the increasingly unforgiving nature of public discourse.
During his appearance on The Joe Rogan Experience, Gillis acknowledged that the joke had not landed the way he might have hoped. He suggested that the reaction had more to do with the cultural moment than with the joke itself. “Obviously had a lot to do with the climate,” he said. The comedian also revealed that he had handled this controversy differently from the one that cost him his job at SNL years earlier. “The first time I got fired, I kept social media. This time, I just deleted everything immediately,” he said.
That reference pointed back to a fraught chapter in Gillis’s career. In 2019, Gillis was announced as a new featured player on Saturday Night Live, but he was fired after just four days when resurfaced clips from his podcast revealed racist and homophobic comments. SNL said at the time that it had not been aware of the offensive remarks when he was hired. Gillis released a statement about the controversy but notably did not apologize for the comments. The decision to bring him back as a host in October was therefore already a subject of debate before he ever took the stage. For many, his monologue reignited questions about whether he had changed, whether comedy was being unfairly policed, or whether a platform like SNL should have been more careful in giving him a second chance.
Gillis’s appearance on Rogan’s podcast added another layer to the saga. The two men discussed the mechanics of the monologue, the boundaries of offensive humor, and why certain jokes provoke outrage while others do not. Gillis seemed to suggest that he understood why the joke was controversial in the current environment, even if he did not fully agree with the intensity of the response. He also made clear that SNL had not signed off on the material ahead of time, a detail that raised questions about how much oversight the show actually has over what a host says during the live broadcast.
The debate over the monologue remains divided. Some see Gillis as a comedian pushing boundaries and testing what can still be said in a live setting. Others see him as someone whose brand of humor relies too heavily on punching down, particularly at women, and who continues to benefit from an industry that is too forgiving of controversial men. Levy’s video, in particular, tapped into a broader frustration among those who believe that jokes like Gillis’s are not harmless comedy but part of a larger cultural problem. The fact that the backlash occurred during the same period as the Cornell rape allegations only made the conversation more charged.
For his part, Gillis has not issued a formal apology for the monologue. By deleting his social media accounts, he appeared to be stepping back from the immediate storm rather than engaging with it directly. His decision to speak at length on Rogan’s podcast suggests, however, that he was not willing to let the moment pass without offering his side of the story. Whether his explanation will change any minds remains unclear. What is clear is that the controversy has become yet another chapter in Gillis’s complicated relationship with Saturday Night Live and with the broader public. From being hired and fired in a matter of days to returning as a host and sparking a new firestorm, his history with the show has been anything but smooth. And with the monologue still being discussed in podcasts, interviews, and social media posts, the conversation around what happened that October night is far from over.
