Alito Court: A rare interview with influential Supreme Court justice

In His Own Words: Samuel Alito Opens Up on Baseball, Dobbs, and the American Dream

On a quiet afternoon in Hamilton Township, New Jersey, Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito stood once more on the gritty baseball field where he had played as a boy. He paused, looked down, and studied the dirt with an infielder’s eye. The pebbles were bigger back then, he said. The surface was more uneven. Those details might seem trivial to a casual visitor, but Alito saw them as more than nostalgia. A rougher infield, he explained, makes it harder to field ground balls cleanly. That was the kind of detail that mattered to a kid who loved the game.

Alito played second base. His best friend Ronnie was the shortstop. “He had a stronger arm, so we were the double-play combination,” Alito said, then stopped himself with a laugh. “In my fantasy, we did it all the time. But maybe we did it once or twice.”

Baseball was not a fair-weather passion for the young Alito. His beloved Philadelphia Phillies were among the worst teams in Major League Baseball. That did not matter to him. “It’s a sign of bad character if you abandon your team just because they’re having a bad streak,” he said. “Some people would think I could be quite stubborn, but I’ve stuck with the Phillies through thick and thin. Hope springs eternal.”

It has been sixty years since Alito last played on that field or walked the corridors of his old high school nearby. In those days, he was not just a student. He was valedictorian, student council president, editor of the student newspaper, and a key member of the debate and track teams. Standing there again, he looked around and said, “It seems familiar, and also seems somewhat different.”

On this day outside Trenton, Alito was dressed casually in a rumpled polo shirt and khakis. Without his black robe, he went largely unrecognized. No one seemed to realize that the man standing quietly on the bleachers was one of the most influential Supreme Court justices of the modern era.

A Portrait He Rejects

The current Supreme Court is known as the “Roberts Court,” after Chief Justice John Roberts. Roberts is often the justice most frequently in the majority. But in many ways, Alito has become the Court’s conservative leader. His legal views on abortion, affirmative action, voting rights, and religious liberty are now law of the land.

To critics, that makes Alito a troubling figure, someone they say is taking away rights from women and minorities. He has been described in some news accounts as “angry,” his decisions fueled by “grievance” or a desire for “revenge for the ’60s.” Alito says that portrait is unrecognizable.

“The idea that I’m angry and that I’m bitter and that I’m trying to get revenge for something that I experienced at an earlier point in my life is a caricature,” he said.

He says he is simply applying the Constitution as its framers intended. But his impact goes beyond his own vote. Among the nine justices, Alito is especially skilled at bringing together five justices for a majority on the most difficult and contentious issues. That includes his 5-4 majority decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, which overturned Roe v. Wade and returned the abortion question to the states.

There is an apparent contradiction: the justice often publicly portrayed as unyielding and inflexible is, behind the scenes, the conservative who is uniquely adept at finding common ground on deeply divisive issues. That skill, Alito suggested, was formed on the fields and in the classrooms of Hamilton Township. Focus, attention to detail, loyalty, a quiet leadership style, and the ability to survey the playing field and adjust—all of it combined to make the winning play.

Alito is almost repelled by the public spotlight. Still, he has written his first book, “So Ordered: An Originalist’s View of the Constitution, the Court and Our Country.” A collection of his speeches, the book is both a defense of his “practical originalist” approach and a warning that America’s constitutional system is under growing institutional and cultural strain. He agreed to talk about it in a rare television interview, sitting for several hours in his hometown and at the Supreme Court.

Considering Retirement

After two decades as a justice, Alito said he considered retirement earlier this year. Now 76 years old, he acknowledged, “It’s something I think that somebody at my age has to think about every term.” Some conservatives had urged him to step down while Republicans controlled the Senate, so that President Trump could nominate his replacement. Alito said that was not a factor.

“It’s too hard to predict what the political situation will be,” he said, “and what any president might do with respect to a replacement.”

Sitting in one of the Court’s formal conference rooms, with gilded paintings of former chief justices on the richly paneled walls, he was asked whether he thought about his role and influence when deciding to stay. “I think I can still make a contribution,” he said. “And it’s hard to give up the opportunity to do something that I think will be good for the Constitution and good for the country as long as I’m able to do it.”

He refused to contemplate his legacy, saying no justice should ever consider it. But pressed further, he detailed a coherent body of work since joining the Court. He said the Court has “stood up for freedom of speech, which is endangered” and has “done a lot to protect religious liberty.” He pointed to what he called an “alarming picture” at colleges and universities. He said the Court has “vindicated the principle that the laws should be applied equally to everybody, regardless of race or ethnic background” and has “tried to restore the original structure of the government as it was set out in the Constitution—but that’s an ongoing project.”

Critics see those decisions very differently. They say the Court has empowered a corrupt president and hurt the country, especially women and minorities. What is beyond dispute is that Alito has done far more than simply contribute. He is the principal architect of the Court’s religious liberty jurisprudence, giving greater protections for people to freely exercise their religious beliefs. In his book, he writes that religious liberty is part of human dignity and warns of a “new moral code” that treats people with traditional beliefs on marriage and biological sex as bigots.

On voting rights, Alito’s opinions set the stage for his majority decision last term in Louisiana v. Callais, which said the state’s 2024 congressional map adding a second majority Black district was unconstitutional. That landmark ruling restricts states from grouping voters together based on race when drawing legislative districts.

The Leak and Its Aftermath

The opinion that will most define Alito is Dobbs. Months before the Court released the decision, a copy of his draft opinion was leaked to Politico—an unprecedented breach that Alito said has had lasting consequences for the Court and for how the justices interact.

“The leak has cast a pall over the Court to a degree because we don’t know who was responsible for that,” he said. “It’s something that I don’t think we can get out of our minds.”

The fallout began in late April 2022, when Politico notified the Court that it had obtained the draft. The justices were gathered in the Court’s private dining room for one of their regular lunches when Chief Justice Roberts told them of the leak. By tradition, the justices eat together when they are in the building for arguments or conference, sometimes several days a week. They talk about anything other than cases. That is the one rule.

Hearing during such a lunch that a draft opinion had leaked for the first time in Court history was difficult to process. Alito said he was “stunned.” Within a short time, he said, the thought occurred to him and to the others in the majority that the leak endangered them. “It made us targets for assassination,” he said.

Security was ramped up immediately. A month later, the world understood why. In the middle of the night, as Justice Brett Kavanaugh and his family slept in their Maryland home, a would-be assassin approached their backyard with a bag containing a gun and ammunition, a knife, nail punch, duct tape, zip ties, a crowbar and other burglary tools, including special shoes meant to silence his footsteps.

He intended to kill justices before the Court released Dobbs. With a narrow 5-4 majority, it would only take one justice. He told private messaging boards that he aimed to kill at least three of the conservatives and, as prosecutors later put it, “single-handedly and irrevocably to alter an entire branch of the United States government.” At the last minute, he called his sister on his cell phone, and she managed to talk him out of it. He was arrested and later convicted for the attempted assassination of Kavanaugh.

“His goal was to change the decision in the case,” Alito said. “And whoever leaked it knew or had good reason to know that that would be the consequence of leaking it. And Politico knew, or should’ve known, that that would be the consequence of their decision to publish it.” Politico has defended its decision as an “unprecedented view into the justices’ deliberations” that was “plainly news of great public interest.”

The leaker remains unknown. One theory was that a conservative leaked the draft to lock in the five votes in case any justice in the majority wavered. Alito called that implausible. “It’s implausible that any of us would have done that for exactly the reason I’ve mentioned, because this pinned a target on our backs,” he said.

Dobbs also changed how the Court operates. Because of death threats and protests, justices now travel with security and have officers guarding their homes. Justice Amy Coney Barrett has talked about wearing a bulletproof vest. Even family members of justices have received threats.

Asked whether he ever regretted writing Dobbs, Alito’s response was immediate. “No,” he said. Even in light of the personal costs? “No, not at all. It was a privilege to be able to write it. And I don’t regret it, despite what it led to,” he said.

Building a Majority

Dobbs was an especially challenging opinion to write. Five justices—Alito, Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett—believed Roe was wrongly decided. But they had somewhat different views on how the opinion should look. With Chief Justice Roberts in dissent, Thomas was the senior justice in the majority. He assigned Alito the opinion.

“I thought long and hard before I started drafting about what we should say, how it should be said—the structure, the tone,” Alito said, “and what I thought each of my colleagues would agree with and would not want to have in the opinion.”

Few outside the Court understand Alito’s powerful role within it. Assembling and keeping together a majority is the entire game. Liberal icon William Brennan used to say the most important thing for a Supreme Court justice to know is how to count to five. Brennan built coalitions through personal persuasion and strategic compromise. Alito, reserved and unassuming, has a very different approach. His influence is not through force of personality, but through his ability to thread the needle and find a rationale a majority can accept.

“The most important thing to know is to be true to the Constitution. Getting to five is important. But you should not try to get a majority opinion if that means sacrificing something that is important,” Alito said. “I will never adopt a legal rule that I think is wrong, or say something that I think is wrong. But without doing that, there are ways of trying to keep a majority together.”

Flags, Ethics, and External Pressures

It is undeniable that Dobbs has had a lasting impact on the Court and its public standing. Democrats organized political campaigns against the decision. Some states amended their constitutions to protect abortion rights. And it opened justices in the majority to scrutiny like never before, laying the foundation for claims that the Court is corrupt and in need of reform.

Alito faced questions about ethics after accepting a trip to Alaska in 2008 on a billionaire’s private jet. He said he followed the hospitality rules in place at the time, and a federal appeals court judge on the same flight said the court’s legal office told him the trip did not need to be disclosed. But the allegations became part of a drumbeat of scandal. Alito said the constant drip affects public trust. “Drip, drip, drip, this affects the way the public thinks about the Court,” he said.

Then came the flags. The New York Times reported that an upside-down American flag had flown outside Alito’s Virginia home. Later, it reported an “Appeal to Heaven” flag flew outside his vacation home. Critics said those flags were used by some groups to show support for efforts to overturn the presidential election on January 6. Democratic senators Sheldon Whitehouse and Richard Durbin demanded Alito recuse himself from cases involving Donald Trump.

Alito emphatically denied any involvement. In a letter, he wrote, “My wife is fond of flying flags. I am not.” In the interview, he said, “My wife decided to fly a flag. I wasn’t even aware of what she was doing until one of our police officers informed me. And I asked her to take it down. And she did eventually. But she’s a very independent person. And she’s a private citizen. And she has her rights.”

Asked why he did not insist she take it down immediately, he said, “That’s not the nature of our relationship. I don’t actually have the legal right to tell her what to do with a home that we own jointly. Plus I am not the lord and master of our household. That’s not our relationship, and it’s not the one that I want.”

Alito said he believed the flag controversy was part of an effort to force him to recuse himself from the 2024 case involving Trump and presidential immunity. He saw no reason to recuse, and he joined Chief Justice Roberts’ majority decision holding that presidents have immunity for official acts.

The Court in a Political Storm

Because of his expansive views on presidential authority, Alito has been spared the ire of President Trump. Trump has praised Alito as one who “wants to make America great again,” while calling other justices who have ruled against him “fools” and “lapdogs.” Alito said both the praise and the criticism bother him.

“We are not part of any political movement. And we are not attempting to further any political agenda,” he said. “We are trying to interpret the Constitution as best we can and apply it in the cases that come before us.”

He acknowledged that criticism from political leaders on both sides is damaging. “I think it can be quite damaging,” he said. “The criticism of the Court by President Biden and his administration was very harsh. And President Trump has been very harsh.”

A Wall Street Journal study showed Alito has sided with Trump more than any other justice. He insisted he would decide those cases the same way regardless of who was in the White House. “I absolutely sincerely believe that I would. I’m not trying to decide cases to help President Trump,” he said.

He used an old baseball metaphor: judging is like being an umpire calling balls and strikes. If ten balls come in a row, you still cannot call the eleventh a strike. “If the balls are in the dirt, or outside the strike zone, it’s a ball. And that’s how you have to call it,” he said.

But Alito acknowledged that judges, like umpires, make judgment calls. He describes himself as a “practical originalist” who believes the law has to work. If an outcome seems wrong or unworkable, he said, a judge should “go back and check our work.” But in the end, if the Constitution demands that result, it becomes the decision.

He offered a personal example: Murphy v. NCAA, his 2018 decision striking down a federal law banning sports betting. “We paved the way for sports betting throughout the country. And I personally hate gambling. I think sports betting is bad. It’s bad for sports and bad for society,” he said. “But that’s what the Constitution required.”

The Increasing Pressure on the Court

The playing field has changed since Alito joined the Court in 2006. Emergency applications have “gone through the roof,” he said, especially since the beginning of Trump’s second term. In these cases, the Court is asked to intervene without the ordinary briefing and argument schedule.

Alito blamed presidents of both parties for relying more on executive orders because they cannot get Congress to act. “The constitutional system is not working the way the framers intended,” he said. Presidents have become frustrated, he said, and have said, “I’m going to do everything that I can with my own power without needing any assistance from Congress. It puts us in a very difficult situation.”

Both parties are eager to go to court to challenge the other side’s policies, usually picking friendly courts. During the Biden administration, most Republican challenges were filed in Texas. In Trump’s second term, most Democratic challenges have been filed in Massachusetts, Washington, D.C., or San Francisco.

“The district courts in some instances have gone overboard,” Alito said. “And these cases come to us. And we have this constant clash.”

The emergency cases have kept the Court in the center of political controversy. They add to the strains on the justices—heightened security, fear of leaks, and what they see as false attacks implying scandal and corruption. Those pressures have driven the justices to become even more cloistered. Some, including Justice Thomas, have spoken about how the dynamics inside the Court have changed and how much they miss the older, more collegial atmosphere. Attendance at the justices’ lunches has dropped off. Alito said the justices “still work together cooperatively” and have “pleasant interactions, pleasant conversations,” but external pressures have taken a toll.

Losing Friends

Alito said he has lost friends as a result of his decisions, mentioning Dobbs as one example. He has been consistent on abortion since his time on the 3rd Circuit, so the loss surprised him. “Maybe they didn’t anticipate it for that case,” he said. “Or maybe they thought, ‘He’s now amassed such a horrible record that he must be a terrible person.’”

He acknowledged that physical threats and harassment are part of the job now. Liberal justices face threats as well when the Court rules against Trump. “The physical threats and the harassment represent something new in our society, and something that’s quite disturbing,” he said. “It’s a danger. It’s a danger for the courts. And it’s a danger for others in public life.”

Friendship With Stephen Breyer

Despite their public images, justices have friendships across the ideological aisle. Alito was especially close to retired Justice Stephen Breyer. Breyer would burst into Alito’s chambers so often that Alito’s law clerks compared him to Kramer in the sitcom “Seinfeld.” Even though they disagreed in major cases, they had similar methodologies. Both were pragmatists who cared about consequences. Both had a similar, self-deprecating sense of humor.

“He is a brilliant man and very erudite. But he wears his erudition lightly, and doesn’t take himself too seriously. I do miss him. He lit up lunch time, every time we had lunch,” Alito said, smiling. “And he would pop in here to talk about all kinds of things. He would pop in here to talk about cases. But he would also come in to talk about whatever he happened to be interested in at the time, literature or music or things that were going on in the world. And it was delightful.”

Breyer called Alito “a good friend” and said they did not always reach the same conclusions but he was “always interested in what he thinks.” Breyer said their relationship is a good example of a simple fact he noticed over the years: “We can be personal friends without always agreeing about legal results.”

Alito pointed out a picture from his welcome dinner, another Court tradition, displayed near his desk. When a new justice joins the Court, the second-most-junior justice organizes a dinner in their honor. Breyer was in charge of Alito’s dinner. Near the end, Breyer announced a special guest and opened the door. In walked the Philly Phanatic, the mascot of the Philadelphia Phillies. Alito keeps the photo on a shelf, what he calls his “little baseball museum” of Phillies paraphernalia and personal items.

The American Dream

Alito’s chambers reflect his personality. The office has no pretensions. The red carpet with gold stars from Justice Anthony Kennedy’s era is gone. Shelves overflow with books and keepsakes. Above the fireplace, Alito keeps his “prized possession”: a copy of his father’s birth record, given to him by the Italian Embassy after his confirmation.

The date on the birth record reveals it took two days for someone to walk to town to report that Alito’s father was born. The entry was written by a local official, not by a relative. “Neither of these two people who walked to town could read or write … so the official had to do it. So it’s a meaningful document for me,” Alito said.

His father came to the United States from a small village in Italy as a child and grew up in poverty. His mother’s parents also immigrated from Italy as peasants, seeking a better life. Both became educators with advanced degrees. His father was a lawyer and public official. His mother became a trailblazing high school principal.

“They really did believe in the American dream, and they believed in the fundamental values that underlie our country … the view that’s expressed in the Declaration of Independence that all people are created equal and that they’re endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights,” Alito said. “That’s how I was raised. But it’s not just how I was raised. It’s what I believe, and what I believed after a lifetime of education and experience. I still believe in all of that.”

Near the birth certificate is Alito’s own official Supreme Court portrait, to be displayed in the Court after his death. In the painting, Alito stands in the Court’s Great Hall in his black judicial robe. In the background are everyday people coming into the Court. The two images together tell a striking story—the humble origins of the father and the achievements of the son.

“It is the American dream,” Alito said. “And it’s been a dream that’s been realized by generation after generation.”

Share This Article
mediawatchbot
29 Min Read