Taylor Frankie Paul Jokes About Applying for The Bachelor After Her Bachelorette Season Was Put on Hold
Taylor Frankie Paul is making it clear that she isn’t done with reality TV romance. Just months after her season of The Bachelorette was shelved indefinitely, the 32-year-old Secret Lives of Mormon Wives alum appears to be throwing her hat into the ring for The Bachelor season 30 — and she’s doing it with a lot of humor and self-awareness.
On Friday, November 30, Paul took to Instagram with a post that had fans doing a double take. “I chose to have the audacity,” she wrote alongside an edited clip from Parks and Recreation featuring Nick Offerman’s Ron Swanson. In the clip, Swanson types on his computer before unceremoniously throwing the device into a dumpster. The overlay on the video read: “ABC going through the submission for the bachelor.” The meme was accompanied by what appeared to be a screenshot of Paul’s application to join the upcoming season of the hit ABC dating series, which will be led by newly announced Bachelor Sam Hartman.
The screenshot showed Paul’s official Bachelorette headshot and listed her height as 5’4”. Under the question “What do you think would make you stand out amongst the other ladies?” Paul seemingly wrote, “Ahhh I was the first bachelorette in history to be put on hold.” The message was a clear and playful nod to the bizarre situation that led to her Bachelorette season being postponed indefinitely earlier this year.
Fans quickly flooded the comments section, with one writing, “Girl get in line like the rest of us.” Paul responded directly, “As you can see I am. I filled out the paperwork like everyone else.” Her response highlighted her willingness to embrace the surreal and self-deprecating humor of it all. Rather than dwelling on what could have been, Paul chose to lean into the chaos and present herself as just another hopeful contestant looking for love.
The post comes after Hartman, a quarterback on the Washington Commanders practice squad, was announced as the new lead of The Bachelor season 30. The announcement was made on Friday and immediately sparked conversation, as Hartman is not a typical Bachelor Nation alum. He has never appeared on The Bachelorette or any other show in the franchise, making him one of the more unconventional picks in recent memory.
Hartman addressed his casting during a Good Morning America appearance on Friday, joking about the challenge ahead. “I have a tough time having a conversation with one girl, [so] 30 is gonna be pretty tough,” he said. “I’m excited but also very nervous.” He also revealed his initial reaction when he learned he had been selected to lead season 30. “Honestly, at first I was like, ‘No way,’” he said. “I got really lucky and talked to Jesse Palmer, and he kind of gave me the insight, what it is and what it’s not.” Palmer, a former Bachelor himself and the current host of the franchise, apparently helped Hartman prepare for what lies ahead.
Before the application post, Paul had already expressed approval of Hartman’s casting. After ABC announced the NFL star would be the next Bachelor, Paul commented under an Instagram post, “Well he’s cute.” She also shared a GIF of herself with a curious expression, making it clear she was paying close attention to the new leading man. That comment now feels even more significant in light of her alleged application to be one of the women competing for his heart.
Paul’s road to reality TV stardom has been anything but smooth. She first gained fame as a breakout star on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, a Hulu reality series exploring the lives of a group of Mormon women navigating faith, friendship and modern life. Her candid personality made her a fan favorite, and in early 2025, ABC announced that she would star in season 22 of The Bachelorette. The news was surprising because Paul was not a former Bachelor contestant, but ABC seemed intent on shaking up the franchise with a fresh and non-traditional lead.
However, her season was derailed before it could even premiere. In March, just three days before the show was scheduled to debut, Disney Entertainment Television announced that the season would be put on hold indefinitely. The decision came after video of Paul’s 2023 domestic violence arrest resurfaced online. The leaked footage showed Paul hitting and throwing chairs at her then-boyfriend Dakota Mortensen, all while her children were present. The video quickly went viral, prompting ABC to pull the plug on her season and leaving fans shocked.
Paul shares a son, Ever, with Mortensen, 33. She also has two older children with her ex-husband, Tate Paul. In the 2023 case, she pleaded guilty to aggravated assault in exchange for the dismissal of additional charges related to child abuse. She completed her three-year probation earlier this year, and she has since spoken publicly about the importance of taking responsibility, learning from her mistakes and moving forward with her life.
At the time of the postponement, a Disney Entertainment Television spokesperson told Us Weekly, “We have made the decision to not move forward with the new season of The Bachelorette at this time, and our focus is on supporting the family.” The statement made clear that the decision was abrupt and indefinite, leaving Paul’s future in the franchise highly uncertain. For a show that has built its brand on second chances, the decision to shelve her season was especially striking.
Now, Paul appears ready to re-enter the Bachelor Nation fold — just on the other side of the equation. Instead of being the lead, she would be one of many women vying for Hartman’s heart if her application is accepted. The twist has delighted fans, who appreciate Paul’s ability to laugh at herself and turn a disappointing situation into a viral moment. Her willingness to publicly share the application screenshot, complete with a cheeky reference to being the “first bachelorette in history to be put on hold,” shows that she has not lost her sense of humor.
The possibility of Paul joining The Bachelor raises several interesting questions. For one, it would mark an unprecedented move for the franchise. In the past, leads of The Bachelorette have occasionally made appearances on The Bachelor afterward, but it is rare for a former Bachelorette to apply as a contestant. Paul’s candidacy would be unusual, perhaps even more so than her original casting. If she actually joins the cast, she would bring with her a built-in fanbase, a history of legal controversy and a willingness to be transparent about her personal life. That combination could make for compelling television, but it also raises questions about how producers would handle her past and whether viewers would be ready to see her in a new romantic setting.
Hartman, meanwhile, has acknowledged that being the Bachelor comes with pressure. His comments on Good Morning America reflected both excitement and nervousness, and he seems aware that leading a season of one of television’s most enduring reality franchises is no small task. His selection as the Bachelor marks a departure for a franchise that has traditionally chosen its leading man from the pool of contestants who appeared on previous seasons. ABC’s decision to go outside the franchise suggests the network is looking for new ways to attract viewers, just as it did when it chose Paul to lead The Bachelorette.
Whether Paul will actually appear on The Bachelor remains to be seen. Reality TV casting is unpredictable, and a public Instagram post does not guarantee a spot in the mansion. But Paul has already succeeded in generating buzz, dominating the conversation and proving that she knows exactly how to keep people talking. Her ability to turn a setback into a storyline has always been one of her greatest strengths, and her latest post is a perfect example of that skill.
For now, fans are left waiting to see whether ABC will take Paul up on her offer. The network has not commented on her application, and there is no word on whether she has been in contact with producers. But one thing is certain: Taylor Frankie Paul is not going to fade quietly into the background. Whether she is a Bachelorette, a Bachelor contestant or simply a social media commentator observing from the sidelines, she remains one of the most talked-about figures in unscripted television. Her latest move is proof that she knows how to seize a moment, and it appears she is ready for whatever comes next.
