Taylor Frankie Paul Playfully Applies for The Bachelor After Bachelorette Delay
Taylor Frankie Paul is not letting the indefinite postponement of her Bachelorette season stop her from chasing another shot at reality TV love. The 32-year-old former star of The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives took to Instagram on Friday, November 30, with a characteristically cheeky post that appeared to show her application to join Sam Hartman’s upcoming season of The Bachelor.
“I chose to have the audacity,” Paul wrote in the caption, sharing an edited clip from Parks and Recreation. In the scene, Ron Swanson (Nick Offerman) sits at his computer typing before abruptly picking up the device and throwing it into a dumpster. The comedic edit was paired with the words “ABC going through the submission for the bachelor,” and spliced into the footage was what appeared to be a screenshot of Paul’s application.
The alleged application included Paul’s headshot from her ill-fated Bachelorette run, with her height listed as 5’4”. Under the question, “What do you think would make you stand out amongst the other ladies?” Paul seemingly wrote: “Ahhh I was the first bachelorette in history to be put on hold.” The self-aware answer was an obvious reference to the drama surrounding her own season, which was shelved before it could ever premiere.
Fans quickly flooded the comments section with reactions. One person wrote, “Girl get in line like the rest of us,” to which Paul responded, “As you can see I am. I filled out the paperwork like everyone else.” The exchange only added to the playful tone of the post, suggesting that Paul is more than willing to laugh at her own circumstances.
Paul’s post came on the same day that Hartman was officially announced as the new lead of The Bachelor. The Washington Commanders practice-squad quarterback is a surprising pick for the long-running reality dating franchise, which has historically drawn many of its leads from its own pool of alumni. Hartman, by contrast, arrives with no prior reality television experience, making his casting one of the more unconventional choices in recent memory.
Paul, however, seems to approve of the choice. In addition to her Instagram post, she commented “Well he’s cute” under ABC’s casting announcement for Hartman. She also shared a GIF of herself with a curious expression, making her interest clear. The comment was quick, playful, and unmistakable.
Hartman himself addressed the surprising news during an appearance on Good Morning America on Friday. “I have a tough time having a conversation with one girl, so 30 is gonna be pretty tough,” he joked. “I’m excited but also very nervous.” He went on to explain his initial reaction when he learned he had been selected to lead season 30. “Honestly, at first I was like, ‘No way,’” he said. “I got really lucky and talked to Jesse Palmer, and he kind of gave me the insight, what it is and what it’s not.”
Palmer, who hosts The Bachelor and is himself a former lead, has become something of a guide for incoming stars of the franchise. His advice appears to have helped Hartman feel more prepared for the whirlwind ahead, even as the quarterback remains candid about his nerves. The combination of Hartman’s self-deprecating humor and his unconventional background has already made him a topic of conversation among Bachelor Nation fans.
For Paul, the road to this moment has been anything but smooth. She was originally slated to star in season 22 of The Bachelorette, a casting choice that itself generated significant buzz. Unlike most Bachelorette leads, Paul did not come from The Bachelor franchise; she rose to fame on The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. Her selection was seen as a bold move by ABC, an attempt to bring fresh energy to the series. But those plans came crashing down in March.
Just three days before the season was scheduled to premiere in March, ABC made the stunning decision to shelve the season indefinitely. The move came after video of Paul’s 2023 domestic violence arrest resurfaced, reigniting controversy around the reality star. Earlier this year, leaked video showed Paul hitting and throwing chairs at her ex Dakota Mortensen while in the presence of her children. The video was widely circulated online, and the backlash was immediate.
Paul shares a son, Ever, with Mortensen, 33. She also has two older children with her ex-husband, Tate Paul. The incident in question led to criminal charges, and Paul ultimately pleaded guilty to aggravated assault in the 2023 case. In exchange for the guilty plea, additional charges pertaining to child abuse were dismissed. She completed her three-year probation earlier this year, marking a significant legal milestone.
The fallout from the video was severe enough to prompt ABC to pull the plug on her Bachelorette season. In a statement released on March 19, a Disney Entertainment Television spokesperson told Us Weekly: “We have made the decision to not move forward with the new season of The Bachelorette at this time, and our focus is on supporting the family.” The wording was careful, leaving the door open for a possible future return, but for now, Paul’s Bachelorette chapter appears to be over before it ever truly began.
Despite the professional setback, Paul has continued to maintain a presence on social media, engaging with her followers and sharing glimpses of her life. Her decision to jokingly apply for The Bachelor suggests that she is not ready to walk away from reality TV just yet. It also shows a willingness to lean into the irony of her situation. After being chosen as the first Bachelorette in history to be put on hold, she is now positioning herself as just another applicant hoping to catch the attention of the new Bachelor.
Whether her application is genuine or simply a social media bit remains unclear. The screenshot she shared was not independently verified, and she did not explicitly say whether she had actually submitted paperwork to casting producers. But the post accomplished what all good reality TV promo is meant to do: it got people talking. Fans responded in the comments, with one person writing “Girl get in line like the rest of us” and Paul replying, “As you can see I am. I filled out the paperwork like everyone else.”
The timing of Paul’s post was particularly notable, coming as it did on the same day Hartman was announced as the Bachelor. By inserting herself into the conversation immediately, Paul ensured that she would be part of the buzz surrounding season 30. Whether or not she appears on the show, she has already made her pitch to the public.
There is also a certain symmetry to Paul’s situation. She and Hartman are both unconventional choices for the franchise. Paul was an outsider chosen to lead The Bachelorette; Hartman is an outsider chosen to lead The Bachelor. That shared outsider status might make Paul an appealing presence on Hartman’s season, assuming the network is willing to revisit her casting. However, given the circumstances that led to her Bachelorette cancellation, it seems unlikely that ABC would take the risk of adding her to another high-profile reality show in the immediate future.
Still, in the world of reality television, almost anything is possible. Casting decisions are often made with an eye toward drama, and few potential contestants could bring as much built-in intrigue as Paul. Her legal history would undoubtedly be a topic of conversation, but so would her ability to generate headlines. For a franchise that thrives on unexpected moments, Paul could be a compelling addition.
For now, Paul appears content to keep her options open. Her “audacity” post was equal parts self-deprecating and ambitious, a combination that has served her well as a reality TV personality. It remains to be seen whether ABC will take her application seriously, but one thing is certain: Taylor Frankie Paul is not going to fade quietly into the background. Whether she ends up on The Bachelor or simply watches from the sidelines, she will likely continue to make her presence known.
As season 30 of The Bachelor begins to take shape, Hartman will have plenty of decisions to make. He will need to navigate the pressures of being the lead, the challenges of connecting with multiple women, and the inevitable scrutiny that comes with the role. He has already admitted that talking to one woman is difficult enough, so the prospect of managing 30 will be a test of his composure. But with Palmer’s guidance and his own sense of humor, he seems ready to embrace the chaos.
Whether Paul will be among the women waiting for him when the limousines pull up remains an open question. If her Instagram post is any indication, she would love nothing more than the chance to find out. And if nothing else, she has already succeeded in making her interest known. As she might say herself, she chose to have the audacity.
