From Scandal to Engagement: Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes’ Complete Relationship Timeline
When Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes were photographed looking cozy in November 2022, the images immediately dominated entertainment headlines. The two former Good Morning America cohosts were both still married to other people at the time, and the public was stunned. What had started as an on-air partnership appeared to have evolved into something deeply personal. Over the next few years, their relationship would play out in the public eye, culminating in an engagement announcement in October 2025. Here is the full story of how Robach and Holmes went from colleagues and friends to one of the most talked-about couples in television news.
At the time their romance became public, Robach and Holmes were familiar faces to millions of morning television viewers. Robach had joined ABC News in 2012 and later became a cohost of GMA3: What You Need to Know, while Holmes, who had a long career in broadcast journalism, joined the program as well. The two shared undeniable chemistry on camera, and viewers often noted their easy banter and comfortable rapport. What many did not know was that their professional friendship was deepening behind the scenes. According to a source who spoke exclusively to Us Weekly after the first photos surfaced, the relationship “blossomed from a close friendship.” The source explained that Robach and Holmes had grown especially close during work trips, where they spent long hours together and relied on each other for support.
In November 2022, however, the nature of their bond became a topic of intense scrutiny. Photographs showed the two getting cozy on multiple outings throughout the month, and gossip outlets quickly connected the dots. At the time, Robach was married to actor Andrew Shue, best known for his role on Melrose Place. Holmes, meanwhile, was married to attorney Marilee Fiebig. The photos raised immediate questions about whether their relationships had overlapped, and both television personalities found themselves at the center of a major media firestorm. Neither Robach nor Holmes commented publicly at first, but the images had already sparked a national conversation about workplace romance, loyalty, and the pressures of life in the spotlight.
The fallout was swift. By December 2022, Us Weekly confirmed that Robach and Holmes were “out” at GMA3 amid the ongoing scrutiny surrounding their romance. Their sudden removal from the program stunned colleagues and viewers alike. For weeks, their absence was a topic of speculation, with many wondering whether they had been suspended, reassigned, or fired. ABC has never fully detailed the circumstances of their departure, but the message was clear: their personal relationship had cost them their positions on the show. The pair, who had spent years building their reputations in broadcast journalism, suddenly found themselves on the outside looking in.
Rather than disappearing from the public eye, Robach and Holmes eventually decided to tell their own story. In December 2023, they launched the iHeartRadio podcast titled Amy & T.J., which gave them a platform to address the affair allegations, their careers, and the intricacies of their relationship. In the podcast, the couple claimed that they were both already separated from their respective spouses when their relationship began. They acknowledged that the timing looked messy from the outside, but they insisted that they had not started a romance while living as committed partners with their spouses. Their version of events was met with both support and skepticism, particularly because the divorce proceedings did not wrap up until well after the scandal broke.
The legal timeline only added more complexity. Robach and her ex-husband Andrew Shue finalized their divorce in March 2023. Holmes, meanwhile, reached a divorce settlement with Marilee Fiebig in October 2023. That meant both Robach and Holmes were still legally married when their relationship became public in November 2022, even if they maintained that those marriages were already effectively over. For many observers, that distinction mattered. For others, the overlapping dates remained a source of controversy. The couple continued to address the criticism on their podcast, often expressing regret for how the situation unfolded while doubling down on their belief that they had found a real and lasting connection.
Through it all, Robach and Holmes leaned on each other. They turned their podcast into a platform not just for defending themselves but also for having open, often vulnerable conversations about relationships, family, and personal growth. Listeners who initially tuned in out of curiosity soon found themselves invested in the couple’s journey. The duo also leaned into their shared sense of humor and warmth, reminding audiences why they had connected in the first place. Over time, public perception began to shift. What had once been viewed strictly as a scandal gradually transformed into a love story of two people who had found each other under difficult circumstances and refused to let go.
The biggest milestone came in October 2025. During an episode of Amy & T.J., Robach and Holmes announced their engagement. The moment was emotional and celebratory, particularly for fans who had followed their journey from the very beginning. The couple did not hold back in sharing their joy with their audience, and the news quickly made headlines around the world. It was a full-circle moment for two people whose relationship had started with so much controversy and had now reached a new and deeply personal commitment. Though they have not yet announced wedding plans, it is clear that the engagement marks a major turning point in their story.
Looking back at the timeline of Robach and Holmes’ relationship, a few dates stand out. In November 2022, photographs of the pair surfaced, revealing their close bond and setting off a media frenzy. In December 2022, they were removed from GMA3, effectively ending their ABC careers. In March 2023, Robach’s divorce from Shue was finalized. In October 2023, Holmes reached a divorce settlement with Fiebig. In December 2023, Robach and Holmes debuted their podcast, giving them a new creative outlet and a way to connect with supporters. And finally, in October 2025, they announced their engagement during an episode of that same podcast. Each step along the way has been documented, analyzed, and debated, but through it all, the couple has remained together.
There is no denying that their relationship changed the trajectory of their professional lives. Robach and Holmes were once rising stars at ABC News, and their departure from GMA3 marked an unceremonious end to that chapter. Yet in a strange way, the scandal also gave them something they might not have otherwise found: the freedom to build a life on their own terms. Their podcast allowed them to control their narrative, and their engagement proved that their bond was far more than a fleeting affair. They have weathered public scrutiny, personal loss, and professional upheaval, emerging stronger and more committed to each other than ever.
As they move forward, Robach and Holmes will likely continue sharing their lives with their audience. Whether they choose to document their wedding planning or keep those details private, one thing is certain: their love story has captivated the public for years and will not be forgotten anytime soon. From the scandalous headlines of 2022 to the joyful engagement announcement of 2025, their journey has been anything but ordinary. And for the couple themselves, the best chapter may still be yet to come.
